I make a point to completely turn off my cellphone when I enter a cinema. Not simply on do not disturb – totally powered down. I mention this not to boast, or in the hope that the specter of a film legend will return to congratulate me. I view it as a simple minor indulgences: for at least an hour and a half, I am totally incommunicado. I leave my phone deactivated for the duration of the closing credits as well. It feels decadent to stay put as the audience gradually exit, lit only by the scrolling names.
And, more and more, by the light of the cataloguing app.
In excess of millions of users engage with Letterboxd, a cinema-tracking platform. In the vein of other curated brands, it has evolved into a marker for a particular kind of tastemaker who promotes new releases and finds joy in revisiting vintage films. Members rate and review films, and the most insightful or most profound commentaries become popular, incentivizing film lovers to craft thoughtful responses.
"Unless I articulate my impressions promptly once the movie ends, my critiques are far less clear and eloquent," said a student.
During a recent outing to the cinema, the credits had barely started before the man in the row ahead started composing his assessment. Nearby, a couple lingered, focused on their screens, jotting down their respective thoughts.
The legendary film-maker David Lynch shared some advice: write down every brilliant thought the precise instant it comes to mind. If you don't, it could be forgotten, and, in his words: "If you forget a great idea, you feel like you could commit suicide." While Lynch spoke to hopeful creators, this mindset pertains to the Letterboxd experience.
A student, a young university attendee in New York, invariably drafts his assessments before leaving the auditorium.
"Should I fail to articulate my impressions promptly after the credits roll, my critiques are far less lucid and well-put," he stated. "It requires a while. I take my time, and my significant other isn't fond of it."
Stern attends the movies a great deal – on 182 occasions the previous year – and is on a first-name basis with the theater staff, who occasionally need to kick him out so they can begin cleaning the theater. He thinks it acceptable to take advantage of the credit sequence: "Upon buying a cinema ticket, the credits are included in the film experience."
The platform's most fervent advocates credit the app with reinvigorating interest around a struggling movie business, where output has decreased and unemployment is up. (Letterboxd also boasts the sort of demographics companies seek – its largest group of users is aged 18 and 24, followed by 25 to 35.)
Buzz creates additional buzz; eagerly anticipated movies witness a surge of engagement on Letterboxd right after the initial screenings. The top critique of a divisive movie – "the author succumbed centuries ago yet this adaptation is still the most egregious event that has ever affected her" – has amassed over 50,000 likes. A different recent film generated this contrast to a rival's documentary: "a famous concert movie left in the dust."
"It feels like an addiction," said a marketing professional, a 33-year-old New Yorker who is employed in marketing. He also chooses to compose critiques throughout the end sequence. "Thinking about what you just witnessed, as soon as you experienced it, enhances the artistic experience. It clarifies the key messages of a film. If it produces a sense of a warm hug, that's not necessarily something you remember hours later."
This user feels most compelled to write about a film if it was very good – or terrible. Case in point: he recently sat through a star-driven film. "I found myself so offended by how profoundly awful it was, that I was eager to take out my phone and give it a one-half star review," he said. (This reviewer is a tougher reviewer than other film critics, who gave the film a higher rating, labeling it "ingenious and watchable material.")
Another user, a twenty-eight-year-old New Yorker who manages social media, saw an acclaimed movie at a local theater and lingered to compose the review ("it got five stars"). He has clocked more egregious conduct: people taking out their phones to log the movie they are actively viewing. "That action annoys me," he said.
One of film's longest-running urban legends tells of a screening of an early motion picture that featured a train arriving at a station. Film was in its earliest days and – according to this apocryphal anecdote – the shot of a locomotive charging directly toward the camera frightened the audience so much that people fled in terror.
Over a century later, movie theater manners remains just as questionable. It seems, few people understand how to act in public anymore, especially when the theater darkens: patrons use their phones of the image, smuggle in strong-smelling food, and, as was reported during a cultural moment, at times get into fights.
Some individuals have taken to social media to argue over the appropriateness of using Letterboxd in the credits. When one social media user